|
Below
is a representative list of cases that reflect the diversity, size,
and types of cases we routinely handle and resolve for our clients.
Where matters are part of public record, we have disclosed the settlement
amount. These examples reflect success in past cases only. In no
way do they indicate settlements for future cases. All cases are
unique. Results cannot be guaranteed.
1.
Failure to Properly Treat Ulcerative Colitis
Andrew Aycoth, et al. vs.
Confidential Defendant; Texas. Marc E. Stewart and Blake A. Deady
Gwendolyn Aycoth, age 49,
was a practicing nurse that had recently been diagnosed with ulcerative colitis,
a form of irritable bowel syndrome (IBS). As her symptoms worsened, she sought
GI care and was admitted to a Houston-area hospital. During the hospitalization,
she experienced increasing abdominal pain, hallucinations, and symptoms of severe
or infectious UC. Nevertheless, she was discharged with little change in her
UC treatment plan. A few days later she was admitted to a second hospital where
she was quickly diagnosed as suffering from toxic megacolon, a life-threatening,
infectious/inflammatory bowel condition that can occur as a result of under-treated
UC. Tragically, she succumbed to the infectious process weeks later. She left
behind a husband, a minor son, and an adult son.
The case settled prior to
trial in May 2009 for a confidential amount.
2.
Anesthesia Complications
Evelyn Blanton,
et al. vs. Confidential Defendant; Texas. Marc E. Stewart and
Blake A. Deady
Ms. Blanton,
46 years old and a school teacher with two sons, underwent an elective
hysterectomy at a major hospital. She had been cleared by cardiology
despite her serious cardiac and renal problems. The cardiologist
made it clear to the surgical staff and anesthesiology personnel
that she was at significant risk for cardiac arrest. After the surgeon
had left the OR, Ms. Blanton remained under anesthesia care. For
unexplained reasons, the anesthesia personnel failed to recognize
that her blood pressure and other vital signs decreased significantly
over a period of 15-25 minutes. She then suffered cardiac arrest
and was resuscitated. Unfortunately, she suffered a profound brain
injury due to lack of oxygen prior to and during the arrest. She
now suffers severe speech impairment, lack of mobility, and a general
inability to care for herself. She now requires full-time care.
The case settled
prior to trial in August 2008 for a confidential amount. Ms. Blanton
will receive medical care for the balance of her life.
3. Mixed-Up Biopsy
Julie Damen,
Individually and as Representative of the Estate of Robin Damen,
et al. vs. Confidential Defendant; Texas. Marc E. Stewart and
Blake A. Deady
Robin Damen
was diagnosed and treated for leukemia at a Texas hospital. After
a long and successful course of treatment, he was declared cancer-free.
He, his wife and children celebrated his good fortune. He returned
to the hospital for periodic blood marrow biopsies to ensure that
his cancer had not returned. On one such occasion, the lab mixed
up his biopsy with that of a different patient. He was informed
that his cancer had aggressively returned and chemotherapy was initiated
that evening. A few days later, he was informed of the mix-up and
told that he was indeed cancer-free. With a depleted immune system
as a result of beginning chemotherapy again, Mr. Damen suffered
from severe pneumonia that caused his death.
The case settled
in June 2008 for a confidential amount.
4. Failure to Timely Diagnose Cancer
Bryan Davidson and Debra Lynn Davidson v. Salvador Faus, MD, John
Cochrane, MD and Beeler-Manske Clinic; Cause No. 99-CV-0256 in the
122nd Judicial District Court of Galveston County, Texas. Michael
P. Mallia and Marc E. Stewart.
This medical
malpractice case involved the Defendants' failure to timely diagnose
Bryan Davidson's testicular cancer. The one-year delay in diagnosis
resulted in Bryan Davidson having to undergo eleven rounds of chemotherapy,
including six rounds of "salvage chemotherapy," and two
surgeries to remove portions of his lungs. The chemotherapy and
surgeries left Bryan with permanent and debilitating physical problems.
Debra Lynn Davidson sued for her loss of consortium.
A verdict in
favor of the plaintiff was awarded by a jury on January 30, 2001.
5.
Medical Malpractice / Wrongful Hysterectomy
Misty Dudley
v. Leslie Cohen, MD; Cause No. 2004-34891; In the 61st Judicial
District of Harris County, Texas. Marc E. Stewart and Blake A.
Deady
Mrs. Dudley
was a 32-year-old, married mother of three children. Mr. and Mrs.
Dudley desperately wanted an additional child but fertility problems
made conception difficult. After considerable expense with fertility
treatments, Mrs. Dudley began experiencing bleeding and cramps.
She was examined by Dr. Cohen, whose only recommendation was total
hysterectomy, including both ovaries. Mrs. Dudley was devastated,
but reluctantly agreed, and the surgery was performed about a month
later. No pregnancy test was performed prior to the surgery. During
the surgery, Dr. Cohen quickly discovered that Mrs. Dudley was actually
suffering from an ectopic, or tubal, pregnancy. While tubal pregnancies
are not viable for fetal development and pose a serious health risk
for the mother, it was apparent that the fertility treatments were
working. Nevertheless, Dr. Cohen completed the total hysterectomy
and forever ended Mrs. Dudley's chances of having an additional
child.
The case settled
out of court September 28, 2005.
6.
Surgical Misadventure / Spinal Procedure
Virgil H. Cook,
Jr. v. James Ghadially, MD, and Tenent Healthcare, LTD. d/b/a Twelve
Oaks Medical Center; Cause No. 2002-57461; In the 165th Judicial
District Court of Harris County, Texas. Marc E. Stewart and Blake
A. Deady
In this medical
malpractice case, Virgil Cook complained that Dr. Ghadially negligently
performed a cervical spine surgery. Mr. Cook's esophagus was somehow
torn during the procedure, allowing blood to aspirate into his oropharynx
and into his lungs. Hours after the surgery and while still at the
hospital, Mr. Cook suffered respiratory distress and coded twice.
He almost died. He underwent additional surgeries to correct the
problem. He has now recovered and experiences no future problems
connected to the incident. During litigation, the defendant declined
to make a settlement offer. The case went to trial on August 30,
2004.
A verdict in
favor of the plaintiff was awarded by a jury September 28, 2004.
7.
Automobile Collision
Thomas Boyce,
and Kerry Boyce, Individually, and as next friend of Daniel Boyce,
Sarah Boyce and John-Ross Boyce v. Abel Dominquez and Kinsel Industries,
Inc.; Cause No. 98-56774, in the 215th Judicial District Court of
Harris County, Texas. Michael
P. Mallia and Marc E. Stewart
This negligence
case arose from a freeway collision in which the Plaintiff's vehicle
slammed into the rear of a 2-1/2 ton flatbed truck at a speed of
about 65-70 mph. The flatbed truck was driven by Defendant Dominquez
and owned by Defendant Kinsel Industries, Inc. Kinsel Industries
was doing construction on the freeway. Defendant Dominquez parked
the truck in the left lane of the freeway, or was traveling very
slowly, with no brake lights, taillights, or hazard or caution lights
illuminated. Plaintiff Thomas Boyce shattered both wrists and his
hip, all of which required surgery. He will require more than one
hip replacement in the future.
A verdict in
favor of the plaintiff was awarded by a jury January 31, 2000.
8.
Medical Malpractice / Wrongful Death / Over-prescribing Narcotics by Physician
James Church,
Individually and as Representative of the Estate of Debra Church
v. Edward H. Morris, MD; Cause No.2004-36418; In the 11th Judicial
District Court of Harris County, Texas. Marc E. Stewart and Blake
A. Deady
James Church
was married to Debra Church. Mrs. Church suffered from a history
of back problems that caused her severe pain. Her primary care physician,
Dr. Morris, regularly treated Mrs. Church for her condition. The
treatment was limited to refilling narcotic prescriptions without
actually examining the patient on a regular basis, as evidenced
by the medical records. As time went by, Plaintiff alleged that
Dr. Morris also failed to recognize the classic symptoms of narcotic
addiction and continued filling the prescriptions. Mr. Church awoke
on June 1, 2002, to discover that his wife had died in her sleep.
According to the Harris County Medical Examiner, her death was caused
primarily by "combined toxic effects of codeine, diphenhydramine,
and alprazoluam"--all drugs prescribed by Dr. Morris.
The case was
mediated in June 2005, and settled for a confidential amount.
9.
Adulterated Food at Restaurant
Melinda Zellmer,
Individually and as Next Friend of Meagan Zellmer v. Landry's Restaurants,
Inc. d/b/a The Rainforest Cafe; Cause No. 2003-52490; In the 165th
Judicial District Court of Harris County, Texas. Marc E. Stewart
and Blake A. Deady
Melinda Zellmer
was having lunch with her two young children at the Rainforest Cafe
in Katy, Texas, when she was injured by pieces of broken glass in
her iced tea. The shards cut her cheek and, worse, a piece was swallowed
before she realized what was happening. She sought medical attention
at Christus St. Catherine and was told the ingested glass would
eventually pass naturally. Other medical tests were performed to
ensure that the ingested piece had not torn her esophagus or stomach.
Ten days later she passed the ingested piece at home. The shard
measured approximately 1/2" X 1-1/2". The pain caused
her to faint, resulting in her falling sideways from the toilet
and into her tub. Her head struck the tile and caused a hematoma.
EMS transported her to Memorial Hermann Medical Center. Medical
tests confirmed that she did not suffer a perforated GI tract and,
other than cuts to her rectum, she experienced no lasting injuries.
A verdict in
favor of the plaintiff was awarded by a jury.
10.
Medical Malpractice / Interventional Radiology Error / Blindness
Daniel Ronquillo
et al. v. I. Ray Kirk, MD; Cause No. 2002-59355; In the 11th Judicial
District Court of Harris County, Texas. Marc E. Stewart
Mr. Ronquillo
had been diagnosed with a benign brain tumor. A day before the surgery
to remove the tumor, an interventional radiological procedure was
performed for the purpose of sealing off certain arteries leading
to the tumor. The goal was to limit bleeding during the next day's
surgery. Unfortunately, an error occurred during the radiology procedure
that caused Mr. Ronquillo to suffer permanent blindness in his left
eye.
The lawsuit
settled out of court in January, 2004.
11.
Medical Malpractice / Failure to Diagnose Ruptured Appendix / Kidney Failure
William Cofield
and Rosie C. Cofield v. Judith E. Piner, DO and OSO Bridge Clinic,
PA; Cause No. 05-202-G; In the 319th Judicial District Court of
Nueces County, Texas. Marc E. Stewart and Blake A. Deady
Mr. Cofield
was a barge captain living in Corpus Christi, Texas. On March 3,
2003, he presented to Oso Bridge Clinic and was examined by Dr.
Piner. He was experiencing body aches, a cough, and headaches. He
noted that while it felt flu-like, he also experienced severe abdominal
pain. No physical and/or abdominal examination was performed, although
Dr. Piner later disputed this. No radiology was ordered and no referral
to a hospital or specialist was made. He was diagnosed with "flu
syndrome" and was prescribed medication. On March 8, 2003,
Plaintiff returned to the clinic. He was seen by a physicians assistant.
Plaintiff reported that the symptoms had not ceased and that he
had begun to experience fatigue and night sweats as well. No physical
and/or abdominal examination was performed. Medication was prescribed
and blood tests were planned, but no radiology was ordered. Further,
no referral was made to a hospital or specialist. On March 9, 2003,
Plaintiff presented to the emergency department at Corpus Christi
Medical Center complaining of night sweats, abdominal pain, chills,
fever, difficulty eating, and body aches. He was quickly diagnosed
with a ruptured appendix. The perforated bowel had leaked infectious
bowel contents into his abdominal cavity, resulting in a dangerous
abscess. He underwent surgery to repair the perforation and cleanse
the abscesses and was given strong antibiotics to fight the infection.
Afterwards, he experienced total renal failure as a complication
of the abscess and was placed on dialysis. On March 17, 2004, Plaintiff
underwent a kidney transplant at Methodist Specialty and Transplant
Hospital in San Antonio, Texas. His brother was the kidney donor.
The case settled
out of court in May, 2005.
12.
Automobile Collision
Nguu Luu, et.al.
v. Allstate Property & Casualty Ins. Co.; Cause No. 729745, In County
Civil Court at Law No. 4, Harris County, Texas. Marc E. Stewart
Mr. and Mrs.
Luu were driving with their two children when a drunk driver collided
with their automobile. Mrs. Luu was injured and subsequently died
at Ben Taub Hospital in Houston, Texas.
The claim settled
out of court.
13.
Medical Malpractice / IV Infiltration Injury to Arm / Chemical Burn
Clyde Driskell
v. Memorial Hermann Hospital System; Cause No. 2003-49023; In the
333rd Judicial District Court, Harris County, Texas. Marc E.
Stewart
Mr. Driskell
was admitted to Memorial Hermann-Katy Medical Center for problems
relating to his renal failure. While there, nurses administered
an IV infusion of potassium, pursuant to physician's orders. The
nurses failed to properly monitor the infusion despite complaints
of pain from Mr. Driskell. The infiltration was later discovered,
but not before serious tissue damage had occurred. Mr. Driskell
required debridement procedures and a skin graft for the burned
and necrotic tissue on his arm.
The case settled
out of court in January, 2005.
14.
Medical Malpractice / Wrongful Death / Failure to Properly Treat Cardiovascular
Disease
Mary Ann Fernandez,
Individually and as Representative of the Estate of Robert Fernandez;
The Estate of Robert Fernandez, Victoria Fernandez and Rebecca Felker
v. Bharat S. Patel, MD, PA et al; Cause No. 02CV1164; In the 212th
Judicial District Court, Galveston County, Texas. Marc E. Stewart
Robert Fernandez
was a heart patient who was regularly monitored by his cardiologist,
Dr. Patel. Mr. Fernandez was diagnosed with significant stenosis
of a major coronary artery. Nevertheless, Dr. Patel failed to recommend
surgical treatment for the stenosis. Mr. Fernandez suffered a major
heart attack at work and died. His family members brought suit against
Dr. Patel and his practice group.
The suit settled
just prior to trial in June, 2004.
15.
Texas Deceptive Trade Practices Act (DTPA) / Fair Debt Collection Practices
Act
Lisa Mudd Stephens
v. Gillman Mitsubishi; Cause No. 803,967; In County Civil Court
at Law Number 4, Harris County, Texas. Marc E. Stewart
Ms. Stephens
leased a 2000 Mitsubishi Montero Sport from a Colorado dealership.
She later moved to Houston. In August 2002 she was contacted by
Mitsubishi Motor Credit to inform her that her 3-year lease would
expire in twelve months, but that she could take advantage of a
loyalty promotion wherein she could avoid over-mileage penalties
if she entered into a new lease or simply purchased a new Mitsubishi
from a "participating dealership."
On August 29,
2002, Ms. Stephens contacted Gillman Mitsubishi North about the
program and was ultimately told that "it would be no problem."
She then bought a new Mitsubishi, leaving her 2000 Montero Sport
at Gillman.
About six (6)
weeks later, Ms. Stephens received a telephone call from Mitsubishi
Motor Credit's Collections Department. She was shocked to learn
that Mitsubishi Motor Credit still expected monthly lease payments
on her former vehicle--the one she already turned over to Gillman
Mitsubishi. Ms. Stephens later learned that Gillman Mitsubishi was
not a "participating dealership" in the loyalty promotion.
The case settled
out of court on May 24, 2004.
16.
Texas Deceptive Trade Practices Act (DTPA)
Sandra
Rowland vs. Texas Longhorn Motors, Inc. D/B/A Longhorn Motor Co.;
Cause No. 741661; In the County Civil Court No. 1, Harris County,
Texas. Marc E. Stewart
Ms. Rowland,
a young single mother, purchased a 1992 Mazda MX-3 from Viva Auto,
which was owned by Longhorn Motor Company (Longhorn) of Houston.
Only two days later, the car had significant transmission problems.
Viva Auto offered to investigate the problem. It was to be a free
inspection. Without Mrs. Rowland's authorization or consent, expensive
repairs were made to the car. She was informed that they would not
release the car to her until she paid the repair bill.
A DTPA lawsuit
was filed against Longhorn, who then answered the suit without the
assistance of an attorney. Plaintiff filed a Motion for Summary
Judgment, which was granted by the court when no representative
of Longhorn appeared at the hearing.
Judgment was
entered in favor of the plantiff by a court following a jury trial.
What's your situation? Let's talk about it.
Call
Toll-Free Today: 877-650-6080
or email
us and we'll contact you.
PRINCIPAL
OFFICE / TEXAS
877-650-6080
or 713-650-6080 | Fax 713-650-6086
442 Heights Boulevard | Houston,
Texas 77007
marc@marcstewartlaw.com
ARKANSAS
877-650-6080
| Fax 713-650-6086
1311 Central Avenue | Hot Springs, Arkansas 71901
marc@marcstewartlaw.com
|
|